HomeStars vs Google reviews for Ontario contractors: what each one does for you
How HomeStars and Google reviews differ for Ontario contractors: who runs them, how reviews are checked, the Star Score and badges, and which to ask for first.
By the GMB Helper team8 min read
For most Ontario contractors, Google reviews should come first, because they sit on your Google profile in the Search and Maps results people already use to find a trade. HomeStars comes second, as a Canadian review site some homeowners check before they hire, and it matters more for big-ticket work like renovations and roofing. You don’t have to choose one. You do have to choose which link goes in the first ask.
We read Google’s review policies and help pages, and HomeStars’ own pages for pros, on Nov 20, 2026. HomeStars blocks automated reading of some of its pages, so where we rely on its blog or on press coverage we say so. We don’t have survey data we trust on where Ontario homeowners look first, and we won’t make up a number.
Google vs HomeStars
The short answer: ask for the Google review first
A Google review shows wherever someone finds you on Google, and Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking. A HomeStars review shows on HomeStars. Both are free to collect, and you can reply to reviews on both. Start every request with the Google link, then add HomeStars once Google has a steady flow.
Who runs each one
Google reviews belong to Google: they sit on your free Google Business Profile, and Google’s own content policy decides what stays up. HomeStars started in 2006. HomeAdvisor, then owned by IAC, bought it in February 2017, and HomeStars is now one of the brands of Angi Inc., which IAC spun off as its own public company on March 31, 2025. Angi lists HomeStars as its Canadian brand.
That matters for one reason: each site’s owner sets the rules for your reviews. A review on HomeStars follows HomeStars’ rules and shows on HomeStars. A review on Google follows Google’s and shows on Google. Neither one moves over to the other.
Google reviews
Priya S.
New shingles on our bungalow in two days, and they cleaned up every nail. Fair quote, no surprises.
Response from the owner
Thanks Priya. Glad it went quickly, and call us if anything looks off after the first big storm.
How Google checks reviews
Anyone signed in to a Google account can review a place, and every review is public with the reviewer’s name. Google’s Maps team wrote in 2022 that every review goes to its moderation system as soon as it’s posted, where machines look at the account’s history and at unusual activity at the place, with human operators behind them.
Google doesn’t ask reviewers to prove they hired you. Its rules work the other way, by banning things. Google’s content policy bans reviews paid for directly or in kind, offering incentives such as discounts or free work for a review, and selectively asking only happy customers. Its restrictions page says a profile caught with fake reviews can be blocked from new reviews for a while and show a warning to customers.
The upside of Google’s open door is reach. Your rating and review count show next to your name in the Maps results, before anyone clicks. The downside is that a competitor or a stranger can leave a fake one too, and you have to report it. Our guide to reporting a fake Google review covers that.
HomeStars profile check
A new review in the last 3 months
Replies to every review
Verified badge
Check when it renews.
Photos of finished jobs
How HomeStars scores and badges work
HomeStars shows a Star Score out of 100% instead of a plain average. Its pages for pros say the score blends four things: your average rating, how recent your reviews are, your reputation and your responsiveness. HomeStars also says its staff vet homeowner reviews before they’re published.
Recency is the part to watch. HomeStars’ blog says a pro’s score declines when no new review has been published on the profile for 3 months or longer. So a profile with a burst of reviews two years ago and nothing since loses ground. That alone is a reason to keep asking every month, not in bursts.
The HomeStars Verified badge is a check of the company, not of a review. HomeStars says it covers a criminal record check run by a third party, a soft credit check, HST registration and trade licences. The badge has to be renewed, and HomeStars’ own pages give both two and three years for that, so check the date on yours. It doesn’t say the check covers insurance, so homeowners should still ask for your certificate.
HomeStars also hands out a yearly Best of Award. The criteria HomeStars has published include a Star Score of 85% or higher, a minimum number of approved reviews in the calendar year (6 or 12, depending on the category) and the Verified badge. Check the current year’s rules with HomeStars before you plan around it, because it says it can change them.
What each one costs you
Google costs nothing. There’s no paid tier for Google reviews, and Google says there’s no way to pay for a better local ranking. HomeStars lets you set up a free profile and collect reviews on it. It sells paid memberships on top, and going by contractors’ accounts of its sales calls, the leads HomeStars sends out go to paid members. HomeStars doesn’t post membership prices, so get a written quote.
If a HomeStars rep offers you a paid plan, ask three plain questions: how many leads did it send in your trade and your town last year, do you pay for leads where the homeowner never answers, and can you cancel monthly. Leads are a separate product from reviews. Your reviews stay on your profile either way.
Local results
Ridgeback Roofing
4.8 (141) · Roofing contractor · 2.4 km
Tallpine Roofing
4.9 (58) · Roofing contractor · 1.1 km
Kessler Roof & Siding
4.7 (92) · Roofing contractor · 3.0 km
Where Ontario homeowners see each one
We don’t have a trustworthy survey of where Ontario homeowners look first. What we can describe is where each review shows. A Google review sits on your profile whenever someone searches your trade and town on Google or looks up your name. A HomeStars review reaches people who go to HomeStars, or who click your HomeStars page in Google’s results.
That difference in reach is why we put Google first. Someone who types roofer oakville sees star ratings and review counts for the top three before clicking anything. The HomeStars review only reaches them if they go looking for it. If someone searches your company name, though, your HomeStars page may show in the results too, so a stale one is something they can find.
When HomeStars should get more of your effort
There’s a fair case for HomeStars, and it’s strongest for big jobs. In our view, a homeowner choosing someone for a full basement finish or a new roof is the one most likely to check a second site, and HomeStars’ vetting and Verified badge give them something Google doesn’t: a check on the company itself. If you sell renovation or roofing work, a strong HomeStars profile helps close the job after Google found it for you.
It also makes sense if you already pay for HomeStars leads. Paying for leads while your profile has a low score is paying to send homeowners to a page that talks them out of you. And if your Google profile is already strong, with steady reviews every month, adding HomeStars is a cheap way to cover the homeowners who check there.
The case against leaning on HomeStars alone is the same reach problem. Emergency work, like a burst pipe or a furnace that quit, gets booked fast, often from the first few names on Google Maps. For that kind of work, a HomeStars profile with 80 reviews does little if your Google profile has 6.
How to ask for both without annoying anyone
- Ask every customer, not only the ones you expect to be happy. Google bans selective asking, and an honest mix of reviews reads as real.
- Put one link in each message. The Google link goes in the first ask after the job.
- For bigger jobs, ask again a week or two later with the HomeStars link, saying it helps other homeowners in Ontario check you out.
- Never offer a discount, a gift or a draw entry for a review on either site.
- Reply to every review on both sites in a sentence or two, good or bad.
If you send these asks by email or text in Canada, Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation applies to them. Customers who paid you for a job in the last two years have usually given implied consent, but the message still needs your business name, a way to reach you and a way to opt out. Our guide to CASL and asking for Google reviews in Canada has the details and a sample text.
Questions people ask
Can I copy my HomeStars reviews onto Google?
No. A Google review has to be written by the customer from their own Google account. You can ask a HomeStars reviewer to leave a Google review too, in their own words. Don’t write it for them or paste their HomeStars text under their name.
Do HomeStars reviews help my Google Maps ranking?
Google doesn’t say so. Its ranking help page talks about reviews on your Google profile and links to your website from other sites. Your HomeStars page can link to your website, which is a link like any other, but we wouldn’t count on HomeStars reviews to move your spot on Google Maps.
Is HomeStars only for contractors?
It’s built around home improvement and home services. If your customers are homeowners in Ontario, check whether HomeStars has a category for your trade. If your customers are businesses, Google matters far more.
How many reviews do I need on each?
There’s no fixed number on either. On Google, compare yourself with the three businesses that show up first for your main search in your town. Our guide to how many Google reviews you need walks through that math.
Our team gets the Google side right
We’re based in Burlington. Our team replies to every Google review in your voice, reports the fake ones, posts your job photos every week, lists you on 50+ directories including HomeStars, and checks your spot on Google Maps every week, with a report every Monday.
Built for home service companies in the US and Canada, 1 to 5 locations.
